Skip to content
← Explore another subjectGCSE · 1HI0

The process of change: Crime and punishment in Britain, c1000–present

Edexcel History (1HI0) · Option 10: Crime and punishment in Britain, c1000–present and Whitechapel, c1870–c1900: crime, policing and the inner city

ONE COMPLETE FREE SECTION

Your course level

This syllabus has no tier selection.

The sample stays complete. Sign up when you’re ready to continue the unit.

0 highlighted

The process of change: Crime and punishment in Britain, c1000–present

This section is the frame for the whole thematic study.

Read it first, then come back to it after each key topic.

Section B of Paper 1 (Questions 3 to 6) is built on the ideas here.

You need to know how key features in the development of crime and punishment were linked with the key features of society in Britain in the periods studied.

You need an understanding of the nature and process of change: patterns of change, trends and turning points, and the influence of factors inhibiting or encouraging change within periods and across the theme.

The key factors are: attitudes in society; individuals and institutions (Church and government); science and technology.

You also need to understand how factors worked together to bring about particular developments at particular times, and how the selected case studies in each period exemplify, in context, the other content, so that you can explore the operation of the key factors and make detailed comparisons over time.

How Section B examines the thematic study

Question

What it asks

Marks

How it is marked

3

Explain one way in which something in one period was similar to or different from the same thing in another

4

Two levels: state the similarity or difference, then give specific detail from both periods

4

Explain why something happened or changed, with two prompts

12

Four levels; without three or more aspects of content the most you can get is 8

5 or 6

A claim in quotation marks: How far do you agree? Two prompts

16 + 4 for spelling, punctuation, grammar and specialist terms

Four levels; without three aspects the most is 11; the judgement earns the last mark in each level

In Question 4, explain causes only: there are no marks for ranking them or deciding which mattered most, and you do not need a conclusion.

In Questions 5 and 6, a "for and against" or "true to an extent" structure is sound, but it only reaches the top level if you explain the criteria you are judging by (more people affected, longer-lasting impact, acting as a catalyst) and keep your judgement running through every paragraph.

In Questions 4, 5 and 6 the two prompts count towards your three aspects, but the third must be your own.

The prompts are only reminders: if you do not recognise one, leave it out and use other knowledge.

There is no lower cap: an answer with only two aspects can still reach Level 3 if it explains well.

Each question gives its dates, and they are hard limits: material from outside the dates earns nothing.

Section B is about Britain: an example from another country earns nothing.

The four periods

The course runs from c1000 to the present, in four periods.

Use these names and dates exactly as the questions print them.

Period

Name used in questions

Dates

1

Crime and punishment in medieval England (the medieval period)

c1000–c1500

2

Crime and punishment in early modern England

c1500–c1700

3

Crime and punishment in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Britain

c1700–c1900

4

Crime and punishment in modern Britain

c1900–present

A numbered century is the hundred years before its number: "the sixteenth century" means 1500-1599, "the eighteenth century" means 1700-1799, "the nineteenth century" means 1800-1899 and "the twentieth century" means 1900-1999.

So the Fielding brothers (1740s-1780) belong to the eighteenth century, and the Metropolitan Police (1829) to the nineteenth.

Examiners report students losing marks because they did not know what a numbered century covers.

The three themes

Inside every period you study the same three themes.

They are the strands that questions are built on, so you can compare one period with another.

  • Crime: the nature of crime and how definitions of crime changed. Crimes are grouped as crimes against the person (murder, assault), against property (theft, poaching, fraud) and against authority (treason, heresy, rebellion, protest).
  • Law enforcement: who caught suspects and brought them to trial: the community, local officials, and later the police.
  • Punishment: what happened to people found guilty, and the purpose of punishment: retribution (paying back), deterrence (putting others off), removal (getting the criminal out of society) and rehabilitation (reforming the criminal).

Each key topic also has case studies: Church influence in the early thirteenth century; the Gunpowder Plotters and Matthew Hopkins; Pentonville and Robert Peel; Conscientious Objectors and the Derek Bentley case.

They show the factors at work in one place and time, and they give you precise detail for comparisons.

Timeline of crime and punishment from 1000 to 1700 with four events marked A to D, from the Norman Conquest in 1066 to Matthew Hopkins's witch-hunts of 1645-47 (see the key).
Timeline of crime and punishment from 1000 to 1700 with four events marked A to D, from the Norman Conquest in 1066 to Matthew Hopkins's witch-hunts of 1645-47 (see the key).
Timeline of crime and punishment from 1700 to 2000 with eight events marked E to L, from the Witchcraft Act of 1736 to the first Neighbourhood Watch scheme in 1982 (see the key).
Timeline of crime and punishment from 1700 to 2000 with eight events marked E to L, from the Witchcraft Act of 1736 to the first Neighbourhood Watch scheme in 1982 (see the key).

Key: A 1066: the Norman Conquest; B 1215: the Church orders priests to stop taking part in trial by ordeal; C 1605: the Gunpowder Plot; D 1645-47: Matthew Hopkins and the East Anglian witch-hunts; E 1736: the Witchcraft Act ends witchcraft prosecutions; F 1749: Henry Fielding's Bow Street Runners begin; G 1829: the Metropolitan Police is set up; H 1842: Pentonville prison opens; I 1868: the last public execution and the last convict ship to Australia; J 1953: Derek Bentley is hanged; K 1965: the death penalty for murder is suspended; L 1982: the first Neighbourhood Watch scheme.

Crime and punishment and society

Crime and punishment always reflected the society around them.

This is the first idea you need: a change in society changes what counts as a crime, how it is policed and how it is punished.

  • Medieval England (c1000–c1500) was a small, rural, deeply religious society. Most people lived in villages where everyone knew everyone, so the community policed itself (tithings, the hue and cry). Kings were trying to show their power, so crime became an offence against the king's peace. The Church was powerful enough to run its own courts.
  • Early modern England (c1500–c1700) was shaken by religious change (the Reformation), a growing population, rising prices and, from 1642, civil war. Changing religion created new crimes against authority (heresy and treason), and fear of the poor and of the Devil created new crimes (vagabondage and witchcraft).
  • Eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Britain (c1700–c1900) became an industrial, urban society. Towns grew fast, people moved away from communities where they were known, and the wealthy feared crime and disorder. The government took on new jobs: a paid police force, prisons and the end of the Bloody Code.
  • Modern Britain (c1900–present) is a democratic, wealthy, technological society. Cars, computers and global travel created new crimes; science created new ways to catch criminals; and changing attitudes ended the death penalty and widened alternatives to prison.

Patterns of change: the words you need

  • Change: something becomes different. Example: from 1829 London had a paid, uniformed police force.
  • Continuity: something stays the same over time. Example: theft was the most common crime in every period.
  • Trend: a pattern of change in one direction over a long time. Example: the government took a bigger and bigger role in law enforcement from c1700 onwards.
  • Turning point: a moment when the direction of change shifts sharply and permanently. Example: the setting up of the Metropolitan Police in 1829 is often called a turning point in law enforcement.
  • Rate of change: how fast change happened. Change was slow in c1000–c1700 and fast after c1750.
  • Progress: change that makes things better (by a criterion you state, such as fairness or how many crimes are solved).
  • Regression: change that makes things worse. Example: the Bloody Code made many minor crimes punishable by death.

Change and progress are not the same.

The Bloody Code was a change, but by most criteria it was not progress.

When a claim says "significant change" or "progress", decide by what criterion before you write.

The factors

A factor is something that encouraged change or held it back.

You need each one as a separate idea.

Examiners report that many students mixed up the themes (crime, enforcement, punishment) with the factors (attitudes in society; individuals and institutions; science and technology).

Know them apart.

Also know that the Church and government are institutions (organisations that last longer than any person), while individuals are single people.

Factor

c1000–c1500

c1500–c1700

c1700–c1900

c1900–present

Attitudes in society

Poaching seen by many villagers as not really a crime (a "social" crime)

Fear of witches and of wandering beggars led to new crimes

Growing disgust at public executions and harsh punishment

Changing views on race, drugs and capital punishment

Individuals

William I's Forest Laws

Matthew Hopkins, the Witchfinder General

Henry and John Fielding; John Howard; Elizabeth Fry; Robert Peel

Campaigners for abolition after the Derek Bentley case

The Church (institution)

Church courts, Benefit of Clergy, sanctuary, trial by ordeal

Heresy laws changed with each monarch's religion

Quakers such as Elizabeth Fry pushed for prison reform; prison chaplains

Little direct role; some church leaders supported abolition of the death penalty

Government (institution)

Kings made crime an offence against the king's peace; royal judges

Laws against vagabonds, witches and treason; the start of the Bloody Code

Metropolitan Police Act (1829); new prisons; end of transportation

Abolition of the death penalty (1965); new laws on driving, race and drugs

Science and technology

Almost none; trial by ordeal relied on God

Printing spread pamphlets about witches and plots

Telegraph, photography and railways helped the police

Fingerprints, DNA, CCTV, computers, cars and radios

How factors worked together

Questions often ask you to judge one factor against others.

The best answers show that factors rarely worked alone.

Learn these combinations:

  • The end of trial by ordeal (1215): the Church (the Pope's council) banned priests from taking part; attitudes among churchmen had already questioned whether God really judged each case; and government (Henry III's council) had to create a new system, trial by jury.
  • Matthew Hopkins's witch-hunts (1645-47): an individual (Hopkins) drove the hunts, but attitudes (deep fear of the Devil, Puritan beliefs), weak government during the Civil War, and earlier government laws against witchcraft (1563, 1604) let him do it.
  • The Metropolitan Police (1829): an individual (Robert Peel, as Home Secretary) persuaded Parliament; government passed the Act; changing attitudes in the growing middle class accepted a paid force; and towns growing with industry made the old system fail.
  • DNA and modern policing: science and technology (DNA profiling, from the 1980s) gave the tool; government paid for a national database (1995); attitudes expected crimes to be solved.

Case studies and comparison

The case studies let you compare like with like across time.

For example, the Gunpowder Plotters (1605) and the Conscientious Objectors (1916-18 and 1939-45) were both treated as threats to the state, but the plotters were hanged, drawn and quartered, while most objectors in the Second World War were given other war work.

That single comparison shows changing attitudes and a changing government view of how to treat people who defy authority.

What you could argue

  • Which factor mattered most overall? Government grew in importance across the whole period: by c1900 it ran the police, the courts and the prisons. But in each period another factor often started the change, such as an individual (Peel, Fry) or attitudes (horror at public executions).
  • Was change steady or sudden? Change was slow for centuries, then fast after c1750. Some historians see 1829 as the great turning point; others see the period c1820-c1870, when the Bloody Code, public execution and transportation all ended, as the real turning point.
  • Was it progress? By the criterion of fairness, ending trial by ordeal and the Bloody Code was progress. By the criterion of crime rates, the record is less clear.
Key terms
  • Factor: something that encouraged change or held it back.
  • Institution: an organisation that lasts longer than any one person, such as the Church or the government.
  • Theme: one of the three strands studied in every period: crime, law enforcement, punishment.
  • Turning point: a moment when the direction of change shifts sharply and lastingly.
  • Continuity: something staying the same over time.
  • Retribution: punishment as paying back the criminal for the harm done.
  • Deterrence: punishment meant to put other people off committing the crime.
  • Rehabilitation: punishment meant to reform the criminal so they do not offend again.
Worked example 1: a difference answer, 4 marks

Explain one way in which the role of the community in law enforcement in the medieval period (c1000–c1500) was different from the role of the community in law enforcement in c1700–c1900. (4)

1. State the difference first: "One difference is that in the medieval period the community was legally responsible for catching criminals, but by the late nineteenth century this job had passed to paid police forces." (AO2: difference analysed)

2. Detail from period 1: "In Anglo-Saxon and medieval England every male over twelve belonged to a tithing of about ten men who had to bring any member accused of a crime to court, and everyone had to join the hue and cry or be fined." (AO1)

3. Detail from period 2: "After the Metropolitan Police Act of 1829, and the County and Borough Police Act of 1856 which made every county set up a force, uniformed constables patrolled beats and arrested suspects, so ordinary people only needed to report crimes." (AO1)

Outcome: Level 2, 4 marks.

With detail from only one period, 2 marks.

A general line such as "people used to catch criminals themselves but now the police do" with no detail stays in Level 1.

Worked example 2: a claim answer that judges factors, Level 4

'Government was the most important factor in changing law enforcement in the years c1000–c1900.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. (16 + 4 SPaG)

Prompts given: tithings; the Metropolitan Police Act (1829).

1. Opening judgement with a criterion. "Judged by which factor made changes last and spread across the whole country, government was the most important factor, but for most of the period it relied on the community, and individuals and the growth of towns often started change, so I mostly agree."

2. Against: the community for most of the period (prompt). "From Anglo-Saxon times until the eighteenth century, enforcement rested on the community. Tithings made every man over twelve responsible for his group, the hue and cry made everyone chase a suspect, and parish constables were unpaid local men. Government set the rules, but ordinary people did the work, so for over 700 years the community mattered more in practice than government."

3. For: government shaping enforcement early (own knowledge). "Even so, government decided the framework. Henry II's Assize of Clarendon (1166) sent royal judges round the country and Justices of the Peace were set up in every county from 1361, so royal government steadily took control of who judged and punished criminals. That kind of change lasted, which supports the claim."

4. For: government creating the police (prompt). "The Metropolitan Police Act of 1829 created about 3,200 paid, uniformed officers in London. Peel pushed it, but only government could pay for a force and make it permanent, and the Acts of 1835, 1839 and 1856 spread police forces across the country. On my criterion of lasting, national change, this outweighs any earlier development."

5. Against: individuals and towns (own knowledge). "Individuals often started change: Henry and John Fielding set up the Bow Street Runners in 1749 before government acted. The growth of industrial towns made the old community system fail. Government acted in response to these pressures, so it was rarely the first cause."

6. Conclusion matching the opening. "The community did most of the work of enforcement until the eighteenth century, and individuals and towns often started change, but government made every lasting change national, from royal judges to the police. So by the criterion of lasting, nationwide change, government was the most important factor, though not the only one."

Outcome: Level 4, 15-16 marks, plus 4 for SPaG with terms such as tithing, hue and cry, Justice of the Peace, Metropolitan Police, constable.

Written with only the two prompts, the same answer could get no more than 11.

With the judgement only in the last line and no criterion, it would lose a mark in each level.

Notice it covers the whole date range of the claim, c1000 to c1900: examiners report answers that wrote only about the first two centuries of a long claim.

Exam tip

Before any Question 5 or 6, write down the claim's factor and two other factors you will test it against, and the criterion you will judge by (lasting impact, number of people affected, acting as a catalyst).

Examiners report that many sound answers stay in Level 3 because they describe change without weighing the named factor against others.

Common mistakes
  • Mixing up themes and factors. "Punishment" is a theme; "government" is a factor.
  • Forgetting that the Church and government are institutions. If a question asks about "institutions", both count.
  • Using an example from another country (such as a famous American prison or a European witch-hunt). Section B is about Britain only.
  • Using examples from outside the dates in the question. A question on c1000–c1500 gets nothing from Matthew Hopkins.
  • Not knowing what a numbered century covers: the eighteenth century is the 1700s.
  • Revising only a few favourite topics. Every key topic has been examined, and any of them can be the focus of Questions 3 to 6.
  • Bringing in material from your other History papers. Only crime and punishment in Britain earns marks in Section B.

Specialist terms for SPaG: retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation, continuity, turning point, institution, factor, Bloody Code, Metropolitan Police.

Check your understanding

1. Explain one way in which the influence of the Church on punishment in the medieval period (c1000–c1500) was different from its influence on punishment in c1700–c1900. (4)

Total [4]

2. Explain one way in which the use of science and technology in law enforcement in c1700–c1900 was similar to its use in c1900–present. (4)

Total [4]

3. Explain why attitudes in society led to changes in punishment in the years c1700–c1900. (12)

You may use the following in your answer:

  • public executions
  • Elizabeth Fry

You must also use information of your own.

Total [12]

4. 'The Church was the most important influence on crime and punishment in the years c1000–c1700.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. (16 + 4 SPaG)

You may use the following in your answer:

  • sanctuary
  • heresy

You must also use information of your own.

Total [20]

5. 'The setting up of the Metropolitan Police in 1829 was the key turning point in law enforcement in the years c1700–present.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. (16 + 4 SPaG)

You may use the following in your answer:

  • the Bow Street Runners
  • Neighbourhood Watch

You must also use information of your own.

Total [20]

Answers

1. One difference is that in the medieval period the Church protected some people from harsh punishment, while in c1700–c1900 Christians worked to reform prisoners (AO2). In the medieval period Church courts tried clergy under Benefit of Clergy and never sentenced anyone to death, and sanctuary let a fugitive shelter in a church for 40 days (AO1). In c1700–c1900 the Quaker Elizabeth Fry visited women in Newgate from 1813 and taught them to read and sew, and new prisons such as Pentonville had chaplains to lead prisoners to reflect and reform (AO1). 4 marks. Accept other valid differences with detail from both periods.

2. One similarity is that in both periods new communication technology helped the police share information quickly (AO2). In the nineteenth century the electric telegraph let police forces send descriptions of suspects between towns, and photographs of criminals were kept from the 1870s (AO1). Since 1900 police have used radios, and the Police National Computer (from 1974) lets any force check records at once (AO1). 4 marks. A difference (for example "DNA is new") does not answer a similarity question.

3. Plan for Level 4: public executions (prompt): by the nineteenth century many middle-class people were disgusted by drunken crowds at hangings, which seemed to teach violence, not deter it, so executions were moved inside prisons in 1868; Elizabeth Fry (prompt, drawn out into a cause): her work at Newgate spread the idea that prisoners could be reformed, and the attitude that punishment should rehabilitate led to the Gaols Act of 1823; own information: juries refused to convict people for minor thefts under the Bloody Code because they thought death too harsh, so Peel removed the death penalty from over 100 crimes in the 1820s; own information: growing opposition in Australia and at home to transportation, which ended in 1868. Each paragraph opens with a reason and ends on why punishment changed. Level 4, 10-12. Two prompts only: maximum 8. Describing what Fry did without saying how it changed attitudes: Level 2.

4. Plan: judgement first: the Church was the most important influence in c1000–c1500, but after the Reformation government took the lead, so judged across the whole period the claim is only partly true (criterion: how long and how widely the influence lasted). For: sanctuary let criminals escape trial; Benefit of Clergy saved educated men from hanging; the Church ran trial by ordeal until 1215. Heresy (prompt): this was a Church idea of crime, yet in c1500–c1700 the monarch decided what heresy was, so it shows government using religion. Against: government made crime an offence against the king's peace; William I's Forest Laws; the Tudors' laws on vagabondage; the start of the Bloody Code; James I's 1604 Witchcraft Act; sanctuary abolished in 1623. Conclusion applies the criterion. Level 4, 13-16; SPaG 4 with terms such as sanctuary, Benefit of Clergy, heresy, Reformation. Two prompts only: maximum 11. Material from after 1700: no credit.

5. Plan: judgement first: 1829 was the key turning point because it created the model every later force followed (criterion: lasting impact on how law was enforced everywhere). For: first paid, uniformed, full-time force in London, about 3,200 men, preventive patrols; spread by the Acts of 1835, 1839 and 1856. Against: the Bow Street Runners (1749) had already shown that paid detection worked, so 1829 built on an earlier change; the CID (1878) began modern detection; Neighbourhood Watch (from 1982) brought the community back into enforcement, showing that 1829 did not end the community's role; DNA profiling (1980s) changed detection as much as 1829 changed patrolling. Conclusion: 1829 changed the most people's experience of policing for the longest time, so it was the key turning point, though later changes were also important. Level 4, 13-16; SPaG 4. Two prompts only: maximum 11.

Ready for the next section?

Create a free account to read the rest of this free unit, save highlights, track your confidence and plan your revision.

Your next step

Put this topic into practice.

These tools belong to this free unit. Create an account to open them and save your progress.

Practice paper · Sign up to open

History 1HI0 Topic 10: Option 10: Crime and punishment in Britain, c1000–present and Whitechapel, c1870–c1900: crime, policing and the inner city. Structured practice

6 questions · Paper 1

Attempt the questions, check the mark scheme and record your own marks.

Create free account to open this practice

Other units and paper downloads depend on your plan. This unit has no Section A quiz; use its other practice and checklist.

Already have an account? Sign in →

Give your revision a routine.

Build a timetable, tick off daily tasks, catch up on missed work and opt in to weekly email reviews. Connect with your teacher when you want to share your progress.