Skip to content
← Explore another subjectAS and A level · 9EC0

The economic problem: scarcity and resources

Edexcel Economics A (9EC0) · Nature of economics

ONE COMPLETE FREE SECTION

Your course level

This AS section is included at this level. The sample stays complete. Sign up when you’re ready to continue the unit.

0 highlighted

The economic problem: scarcity and resources

Every economic question, from what a student buys for lunch to how much a government spends on hospitals, starts from the same fact: people want more than the world can provide.

That gap between wants and the resources to meet them is the economic problem, and it is the reason economics exists.

This section explains scarcity, the resources that economies draw on, and why it matters whether a resource can renew itself or is used up for good.

The ideas return throughout the course: in opportunity cost (next section), in the production possibility frontier, in market failure from overused resources, and in the debates over growth and sustainability in Themes 2 and 4.

On the papers, the economic problem can be set on Paper 1 and Paper 3, usually as Section A items and as a starting point for evaluation in longer answers.

The idea: unlimited wants, finite resources

You need to know the problem of scarcity, in these words:

Key terms
  • The problem of scarcity: where there are unlimited wants and finite resources
  • Economic problem: the need to choose how to use scarce resources, because they cannot satisfy every want.
  • Factors of production: the resources used to produce goods and services: land (natural resources), labour (human effort), capital (man-made aids to production such as machines) and enterprise (organising the other factors and taking risks).
  • Renewable resource: a resource that can be replenished naturally within a human time scale, so its stock can be maintained if it is not used faster than it regenerates.
  • Non-renewable resource: a resource with a fixed stock that cannot be replaced within a human time scale once it has been used.

Wants are unlimited because people's desires grow as their incomes grow.

A household that buys its first car soon wants a second, then a better one, then holidays abroad, then a larger home.

Even if every want of today were met, new products and new expectations would create more.

Resources are finite because there is only so much land, so many workers with so many hours, so much machinery and so much organising talent at any moment.

Put the two together and every economy, firm and household faces scarcity.

Scarcity is not the same as poverty.

A rich country is still short of resources in this sense: the UK cannot have more nurses, more teachers and more soldiers at the same time without having fewer of something else.

Even a billionaire faces scarcity of time.

Because resources are scarce, every society must answer three basic questions:

1. What to produce? Hospitals or roads, phones or bicycles, and in what quantities.

2. How to produce it? With many workers and few machines, or few workers and many machines; with coal or with wind.

3. For whom to produce it? How output is shared between people, by income, need or some other rule.

How these questions are answered is the difference between the economic systems you meet at the end of this unit: free markets answer them through prices, command economies through state planning, mixed economies through both.

Free goods and economic goods

A good is an economic good when it uses scarce resources, so producing it has an opportunity cost.

A free good uses no scarce resources: there is enough of it for everyone at a price of zero, such as the air on a hillside or seawater on a beach.

Free goods are rare, and a free good can become an economic good: clean air in a congested city is scarce, because keeping it clean means fewer car journeys or costly filters.

This idea goes slightly beyond the wording of the course, and it is useful because it shows that scarcity depends on wants and resources together, not on whether something is physically plentiful.

Renewable and non-renewable resources

You need to know the distinction between renewable and non-renewable resources.

  • Non-renewable resources such as oil, natural gas, coal and metal ores were formed over millions of years. Each barrel of oil burned is gone for good. Their stock can only fall, although the amount that is worth extracting can rise when prices rise or technology improves, and metals can be partly recycled.
  • Renewable resources such as fish stocks, forests, fresh water, solar and wind energy, and fertile soil can replace themselves. Some (sunlight, wind) cannot be used up at all. Others (fish, forests, groundwater) can be exhausted if they are used faster than they regenerate.

That second point is where the distinction matters most.

A renewable resource is only renewable if it is managed.

The cod fishery off Newfoundland in Canada, once one of the richest in the world, collapsed after years of heavy fishing, and the Canadian government closed it to commercial cod fishing in 1992; tens of thousands of jobs were lost and the stock took decades to begin recovering.

The cod were renewable in principle and were used up in practice.

The photograph below shows a fishing trawler hauling in its net at sea.

A fish stock renews itself only while boats like this take fewer fish each year than the stock adds through breeding and growth.

A photograph of a fishing trawler at sea winching a full net of fish up its stern. Fish are a renewable resource, but a stock shrinks when boats catch more each year than it can replace.
A photograph of a fishing trawler at sea winching a full net of fish up its stern. Fish are a renewable resource, but a stock shrinks when boats catch more each year than it can replace.

Why does it matter to economics?

  • For consumers and firms, non-renewable resources tend to become scarcer and dearer over time as the easiest reserves are used, which encourages the search for substitutes. UK oil production from the North Sea peaked around 1999 and has been falling since, and the industry has invested in other energy sources.
  • For governments, an economy that depends on extracting a non-renewable resource must plan for the day it runs out or stops being profitable. Managing renewable resources sustainably often needs rules, such as fishing quotas, because no single user has an incentive to hold back: you meet this as market failure in the next unit.
  • For the future, using non-renewable resources now leaves less for later generations, which is a value judgement about how much weight the future deserves.

The photograph below shows an offshore oil production platform of the kind used in the North Sea.

Every barrel it pumps comes from a fixed stock formed over millions of years, so the output of a field eventually falls, however much is spent on it.

A photograph of an offshore oil platform standing on steel legs in a rough sea. Oil is a non-renewable resource: each barrel pumped is gone for good, so the stock in a field can only fall.
A photograph of an offshore oil platform standing on steel legs in a rough sea. Oil is a non-renewable resource: each barrel pumped is gone for good, so the stock in a field can only fall.
Worked example 1: how long will a non-renewable resource last?

A country has proven oil reserves of 2.4 billion barrels and extracts 160 million barrels a year.

1. Years of reserves left = reserves ÷ annual extraction.

2. = 2 400 million ÷ 160 million = 15.

Answer: about 15 years at the current rate.

The figure is a model built on assumptions: extraction stays the same each year and the reserves figure stays the same, ceteris paribus.

In practice a higher oil price makes harder-to-reach oil worth extracting, which raises the proven reserves, while new technology can do the same; and extraction may fall if demand shifts to renewable energy.

The answer is a warning, not a forecast.

Worked example 2: when is a renewable resource used up?

A sea area holds a fish stock of 500 000 tonnes.

Left alone, the stock grows by 12% a year.

Fishing boats catch 75 000 tonnes a year.

1. Natural growth in year 1 = 12% of 500 000 = 60 000 tonnes.

2. Stock at the end of year 1 = 500 000 + 60 000 − 75 000 = 485 000 tonnes, a fall of 15 000 tonnes.

3. Year 2: growth = 12% of 485 000 = 58 200; stock = 485 000 + 58 200 − 75 000 = 468 200 tonnes, a fall of 16 800.

4. Year 3: stock = 468 200 × 1.12 − 75 000 = 449 384 tonnes, a fall of 18 816.

Answer: the stock falls every year, and falls faster each year, because a smaller stock produces less natural growth.

A catch of up to 60 000 tonnes a year would have kept the stock at 500 000.

The renewable resource is being used faster than it renews itself, so in time it behaves like a non-renewable one.

(Real fish stocks do not grow at a fixed percentage; this simple model is enough to show the mechanism.)

Worked example 3: an Explain 4 on scarcity, with a weaker answer

Context. In 2025 a hospital trust in the Midlands received 4 200 applications for planned hip operations but had theatre time and surgeons for 3 100.

Question. With reference to the information above, explain why the hospital trust faces the economic problem.

(4)

Model answer.

  • The economic problem is scarcity: wants are unlimited but the resources to meet them are finite (1, K).
  • Resources such as surgeons' time and operating theatres (labour and capital) are limited at any moment (1, K).
  • The trust has 4 200 applications but capacity for 3 100, a shortfall of 1 100 operations (1, App).
  • So it must choose which patients are treated first, and any resources used for hip operations cannot be used for other treatments, so every choice has an opportunity cost (1, An).

Weaker answer: "The hospital does not have enough money."

Money is not the resource that is scarce here; the answer does not name scarcity, use the figures or explain the need to choose: 0 or 1 mark.

Worked example 4: an Explain 2 on the two kinds of resource

Question. Explain one reason why a forest may be treated as a non-renewable resource.

(2)

Model answer. Trees are a renewable resource because they regrow naturally (1, K), but if they are felled faster than new trees grow, for example when land is cleared for farming and not replanted, the stock shrinks and may never return, so in practice it is used up like a non-renewable resource (1, An).

Weighing scarcity in evaluation

Scarcity drives evaluation in later units.

Use these levers when a question involves resources:

  • Time. Non-renewable resources are fixed in the very long run, but known reserves change with prices and technology in the short run. Ask which time scale the question is about.
  • Substitutes. The more substitutes exist (renewable energy for gas, recycled metals for ore), the less damage running down a resource does.
  • Rate of use against rate of renewal. A renewable resource is safe only while use stays below its natural regrowth: compare the two numbers if the data give them.
  • Who bears the cost. Using a resource now may help today's consumers and producers while future generations pay; how much that matters is a value judgement.
  • Weak forms to avoid: "resources will run out" as a bare statement. Say which resource, how fast and what may slow it down.
Exam tip

Write the problem of scarcity as both halves: "unlimited wants and finite resources".

Candidates often give only one half ("not enough resources"), which leaves out why a choice is needed.

Then go straight to the consequence the question needs: a choice must be made, so there is an opportunity cost.

Common mistakes
  • Scarcity means poverty. It is tempting because poor households obviously go short. Scarcity applies to every person and every country, however rich, because wants always outrun resources.
  • Money is the scarce resource. Money only gives a claim on resources; the scarce things are land, labour, capital and enterprise. A government can print money but not more surgeons.
  • Renewable means it can never run out. Fish, forests and groundwater can be exhausted when used faster than they regenerate; only flows such as sunlight and wind cannot.
  • Treating a reserves calculation as a forecast. It assumes ceteris paribus; prices, technology and demand all change the answer.

Check your understanding

1. Which one of the following is a non-renewable resource? (1)

  • A Wind passing over an offshore turbine
  • B Timber from a managed forest that is replanted each year
  • C Natural gas in an undersea field
  • D Fresh water from a river fed by rainfall

Total [1]

2. A country has 1.26 billion tonnes of coal reserves and mines 90 million tonnes a year. Ceteris paribus, which one of the following is the number of years the reserves will last at the current rate? (1)

  • A 0.07 years
  • B 14 years
  • C 140 years
  • D 1.4 years

Total [1]

3. A lake in Scotland holds a stock of 3.2 million wild salmon. Without fishing, the stock grows by 8% a year. In 2025 anglers and netting firms caught 300 000 salmon.

(a) Which one of the following is the change in the stock of salmon over 2025, ceteris paribus?

(1)

  • A A fall of 44 000 salmon
  • B A rise of 256 000 salmon
  • C A fall of 300 000 salmon
  • D A rise of 44 000 salmon

(b) With reference to the information above, explain why the salmon may be at risk even though they are a renewable resource.

(4)

Total [5]

4. A student says: "Scarcity is not a problem for very rich countries such as Norway." Explain why the student is wrong. (2)

Total [2]

5. Explain one reason why clean air in a busy city centre may be an economic good, not a free good. (2)

Total [2]

6. After a sharp rise in the world price of copper, mining firms announced plans to reopen several closed mines and to invest in recycling scrap copper. Some commentators warned that the world "will run out of copper this century". Assess whether rising prices are likely to prevent the world running out of a non-renewable resource such as copper. (10)

Total [10]

Answers

1. The only correct answer is C. Natural gas formed over millions of years; once burned it cannot be replaced within a human time scale.

  • A is not correct because wind is a renewable flow that cannot be used up.
  • B is not correct because a forest replanted each year is renewed at the rate it is used.
  • D is not correct because rainfall refills the river, so the water is renewable.

2. The only correct answer is B. 1 260 million ÷ 90 million = 14 years.

  • A is not correct because it divides extraction by reserves (90 ÷ 1 260 = 0.07), the wrong way round.
  • C is not correct because it misreads 1.26 billion as 12.6 billion, a factor of ten too large.
  • D is not correct because it is a factor of ten too small.

3. (a) The only correct answer is A. Growth = 8% of 3.2 million = 256 000; change = 256 000 − 300 000 = −44 000.

  • B is not correct because it counts the natural growth and ignores the catch.
  • C is not correct because it counts the catch and ignores the natural growth.
  • D is not correct because it has the sign wrong: the catch is larger than the growth, so the stock falls.

(b) Knowledge 2, Application 1, Analysis 1.

  • A renewable resource can replace itself naturally (1, K).
  • It is only sustained if it is used no faster than it regenerates (1, K).
  • The catch of 300 000 is larger than natural growth of 256 000 (8% of 3.2 million), so the stock falls by 44 000 in the year (1, App).
  • A smaller stock produces less growth the next year, so if the catch stays at 300 000 the stock falls faster each year and could collapse, as a non-renewable resource would be used up (1, An).

4. Knowledge 1, Analysis 1.

  • Scarcity means unlimited wants and finite resources, which applies to every economy whatever its income (1, K)
  • so even a rich country such as Norway has a limited number of workers and amount of land, and must choose between, for example, more hospitals and more roads; using resources for one means giving up the other (1, An).

5. Knowledge 1, Analysis 1.

  • An economic good is one that uses scarce resources, so it has an opportunity cost (1, K)
  • and keeping city air clean means limiting traffic or fitting filters, which uses resources or gives up journeys that people value, so clean air there is not available to all at no cost (1, An).

6. Levels: KAA 6, Evaluation 4. Either side may be the KAA.

  • KAA (rising prices help): a sharply higher copper price is a signal of scarcity and an incentive; it makes reopening "closed mines" profitable, which raises supply in the short run; it makes "recycling scrap copper" worth doing, so less new copper is needed; it encourages buyers to use less or switch to substitutes such as aluminium in some cables; so the rate of use falls and the date at which reserves run out moves further away.
  • Evaluation (they may not be enough): copper is still finite, so higher prices can delay but not prevent exhaustion if demand keeps rising (for electric vehicles and power networks); new mines take years to open, so supply is price inelastic in the short run; recycling cannot recover copper locked in use for decades; substitutes do not work in every use. Weigh which effect is larger and over what time scale.
  • Levels: one developed chain using the context (reopened mines, recycling, the higher price) and one developed counter reach KAA Level 3 (5-6) and Evaluation Level 2 (3-4). Without the case's details, KAA stops at Level 2. No final judgement is needed on an Assess 10.

Ready for the next section?

Create a free account to read the rest of this free unit, save highlights, track your confidence and plan your revision.

Your next step

Put this topic into practice.

These tools belong to this free unit. Create an account to open them and save your progress.

Practice paper · Sign up to open

Economics A 9EC0 Topic t1-1: Nature of economics. Structured practice

1 questions · AS · Paper 1

Attempt the questions, check the mark scheme and record your own marks.

Create free account to open this practice

Other units and paper downloads depend on your plan. This unit has no Section A quiz; use its other practice and checklist.

Already have an account? Sign in →

Give your revision a routine.

Build a timetable, tick off daily tasks, catch up on missed work and opt in to weekly email reviews. Connect with your teacher when you want to share your progress.