Skip to content
← Explore another subjectGCSE · 8145

Overview of the period study: America, 1840–1895: Expansion and consolidation

AQA History (8145) · Option AA (Paper 1 period study): America, 1840–1895: Expansion and consolidation

ONE COMPLETE FREE SECTION

Your course level

This syllabus has no tier selection.

The sample stays complete. Sign up when you’re ready to continue the unit.

0 highlighted

Overview of the period study: America, 1840–1895: Expansion and consolidation

You need to know: This period study (AA America, 1840–1895: Expansion and consolidation) focuses on the development of America during a turbulent half century of change.

It was a period of expansion and consolidation – the expansion to the west and consolidation of the United States as a nation.

Students will study the political, economic, social and cultural aspects of these two developments (expansion to the west and consolidation of the United States as a nation) and the role ideas played in bringing about change.

They will also look at the role of key individuals and groups in shaping change and the impact the developments had on them.

In 1840 the United States was a young country of about 17 million people, most of them living east of the Mississippi River.

Its western edge was a line of forts and trading posts on the edge of the Great Plains.

By 1895 it stretched from the Atlantic to the Pacific.

Railroads crossed the continent, farms covered the Plains, and the Plains Indians had been forced onto reservations.

In between, the country had torn itself apart in a civil war that killed hundreds of thousands of soldiers and ended slavery.

This option follows two big stories.

Expansion is the movement of Americans west across the continent and what it did to the land and the peoples already living there.

Consolidation means making something stronger and more united: here, binding the states into one nation with one government, one economy and one set of laws.

The two stories are tied together.

Arguments about whether slavery should spread into the new western lands helped cause the Civil War, and the Civil War decided what kind of nation would control the West.

This section gives you the big picture first, so every later section has somewhere to fit.

It then explains how Paper 1 Section A examines this option.

The two big developments

1. Expansion to the west. In the 1840s the United States gained Texas (1845), the Oregon Country (1846) and, after the war with Mexico, California and the South-West (1848).

Pioneer farmers took wagons along the Oregon Trail, the Mormons fled to the valley of the Great Salt Lake, and the gold rush of 1848-49 drew hundreds of thousands to California.

After 1862 the Homestead Act and the railroads brought settlers onto the Plains themselves.

Each step pushed against the lands of the Plains Indians.

2. Consolidation of the nation. In 1840 the North and the South had very different economies and ways of life, and slavery divided them.

Between 1861 and 1865 eleven Southern states tried to leave the Union and were defeated.

After the war, Reconstruction (1865-1877) tried to rebuild the South and to give formerly enslaved people freedom and rights.

The Mormons in Utah, who had run their territory almost as a separate state, were brought under federal law.

By 1890 the government had defeated the Plains Indians and the census declared that the frontier had closed.

Four kinds of change you will study

Aspect

What it means

Examples from this option

Political

who held power, what governments and armies did

the Permanent Indian Frontier; the Missouri Compromise; secession; the 13th Amendment; Reconstruction; the reservations; the Dawes Act

Economic

land, farming, trade, industry, money

the gold rush; the cotton economy of the South; Northern industry; the Homestead Act; the railroads; the destruction of the buffalo

Social

how groups lived together

slavery and freedom; Mormon communities; pioneer families; Homesteader women; reservation life

Cultural

beliefs, religion, ways of life and ideas

Manifest Destiny; the Plains Indians' beliefs about land; Mormon beliefs; boarding schools and the attack on Native American culture

A Question 6 can set one aspect against another as its two bullet points (for example "economic" against "cultural"), so learn which events belong where.

The role of ideas

Ideas drove change in this period as much as people and events did.

  • Manifest Destiny: the belief that the United States was meant, by God or by history, to spread across the whole continent. It justified the war with Mexico and the taking of Native American land.
  • The Great American Desert: the belief, strong before about 1860, that the Great Plains were too dry for farming. It made the Plains a place to cross, not a place to settle, and supported the idea of leaving them to the Plains Indians.
  • Abolitionism: the belief that slavery was a sin and must be ended at once. It grew in the North from the 1830s and made compromise with the South harder.
  • States' rights: the belief that each state, not the federal government in Washington, had the final say on matters such as slavery. Southern leaders used it to justify secession in 1860-61.
  • Religious freedom and a separate community: the Mormons' belief that they must build their own society, which drove them west to Utah.
  • Assimilation: the belief, strong after 1865, that Native Americans should give up their own culture and live as white American farmers. It drove the reservations, boarding schools and the Dawes Act.

Key individuals and groups

Who

Role in this option

Joseph Smith

founder of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (the Mormons) in 1830; killed by a mob in 1844

Brigham Young

Mormon leader who took the Mormons to the Great Salt Lake in 1847 and led them until his death in 1877

The Plains Indians

many nations, among them the Lakota Sioux, Cheyenne, Arapaho, Comanche and Kiowa; leaders in this option include Red Cloud, Black Kettle, Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse

Abraham Lincoln

Republican President, 1861-1865; led the Union in the Civil War; Emancipation Proclamation, 1863; murdered in April 1865

Jefferson Davis

President of the Confederate States of America, 1861-1865

John Brown

abolitionist who killed pro-slavery settlers in Kansas in 1856 and led the raid on Harpers Ferry in 1859

Colonel John Chivington

commander at the Sand Creek Massacre, 1864

George Armstrong Custer

cavalry commander killed at the Little Big Horn, 1876

Groups

pioneer farmers; Mormons; miners; Homesteaders; railroad companies; enslaved and freed African-Americans; Southern planters; Northern industrial workers; the US army; carpetbaggers; the federal government and Congress

You also need to know "the impact the developments had on them": how a Mormon's, a miner's, a Homesteader's, an African-American's or a Lakota family's life changed.

Question 5 tests exactly this.

The whole period at a glance

Timeline of America from 1840 to 1895 with eleven events marked A to K, from the first large wagon train to Oregon in 1843 to the Wounded Knee Massacre in December 1890 (see the key).
Timeline of America from 1840 to 1895 with eleven events marked A to K, from the first large wagon train to Oregon in 1843 to the Wounded Knee Massacre in December 1890 (see the key).
  • A: 1843, the first large wagon train, about 1,000 people, sets out on the Oregon Trail
  • B: 24 July 1847, Brigham Young reaches the valley of the Great Salt Lake; six months later, in January 1848, gold is found at Sutter's Mill in California
  • C: September 1851, the Fort Laramie Treaty
  • D: May 1854, the Kansas-Nebraska Act breaks the Missouri Compromise
  • E: April 1861, the Civil War begins at Fort Sumter
  • F: May 1862, the Homestead Act
  • G: December 1865, the 13th Amendment ends slavery
  • H: May 1869, the first transcontinental railroad is completed
  • I: June 1876, the Battle of the Little Big Horn; in 1877 the last federal troops leave the South and Reconstruction ends
  • J: February 1887, the Dawes Act
  • K: December 1890, the Wounded Knee Massacre

Part

Dates (roughly)

The story in one line

Part one: Expansion: opportunities and challenges

1840s-1850s

Americans cross the "desert" to Oregon, Utah and California, and meet the Plains Indians

Part two: Conflict across America

1850s-1860s

war on the Plains; the slavery quarrel and the Civil War; conflict with the Mormons

Part three: Consolidation: forging the nation

1865-1895

Reconstruction; settling the Plains; the defeat of the Plains Indians and the closing of the frontier

Do not confuse: the three groups who went west

The Mormons

Pioneer migrant farmers

The miners

Main time

1846-1847 onwards

from 1843

from 1848-49

Where to

the valley of the Great Salt Lake (Utah)

Oregon (and California farmland)

California, later Colorado (1858-59) and the Black Hills (1874-76)

Why

to escape persecution and build their own religious community

free or cheap fertile land, a fresh start

gold and quick wealth

Who went

whole families and communities, led by their church

families, often in wagon trains

mostly young men, from all over the world

And do not confuse them with the Homesteaders, who settled on the Great Plains themselves after the Homestead Act of 1862.

The early settlers crossed the Plains; the Homesteaders stayed on them.

How Paper 1 Section A works

Paper 1 is "Understanding the modern world".

Section A is this period study: 40 marks, six compulsory questions, about 1 hour.

There is no mark for spelling, punctuation and grammar in this section.

The only thing printed for you is a small Interpretations Booklet with two interpretations, A and B. Everything else, every date, name and number, comes from your memory.

Question

What it asks

Marks

Time

1

How does Interpretation B differ from Interpretation A about a focus?

4

about 5 min

2

Why might the authors of A and B have a different interpretation about it?

4

about 5 min

3

Which interpretation gives the more convincing opinion about it?

8

about 12 min

4

Describe two problems faced by a person, group or government

4

about 5 min

5

In what ways were the lives of a group affected by a development?

8

about 11 min

6

Which of two bullet points was the more important reason, had more impact, or brought more change?

12

about 18 min

Spend about 4 minutes reading the two interpretations first.

Questions 1 to 3 share one focus.

Questions 4, 5 and 6 each come from a different part of the course, and none repeats the focus of Questions 1 to 3.

Every series has tested all three Parts, and the Homesteaders, the Plains Indians and the Civil War come back every year in a different question type, so never treat a topic as "done".

Every question is level-marked: your whole answer is read, placed in the level it fits best, then given a mark inside that level.

The 4-mark questions have two levels, the 8-mark questions four levels of 2 marks, and Question 6 four levels of 3 marks.

Sources and interpretations are different things

In this section an interpretation is a view written or spoken by someone who lived through the events or took part in them, often years later: a memoir, an autobiography, a letter, a speech, a report to the government, a first-person account.

It is never a modern historian.

The author's position, experience and purpose shape the view.

Question 1 asks what the two views say, Question 2 asks why the authors see things differently, and Question 3 asks which view your knowledge supports more.

A source is evidence made at the time, such as a cartoon, a poster or a letter.

Sources appear in Paper 1 Section B and Paper 2 Section A, where the question is how useful they are.

Do not test the interpretations in this section for usefulness or reliability.

Words for the peoples of the Plains

The specification says "Plains Indians" and "native Americans".

Recent papers also write "Native Americans", and "Indigenous" is also used.

All are accepted.

Use the name of a nation (Lakota Sioux, Cheyenne, Arapaho) when you can: it is more precise and earns credit for detail.

"The Indian problem" was the phrase white Americans used at the time for the question of what to do about Native Americans; put it in quotation marks, as the specification does, to show it is their phrase.

Key terms
  • Expansion: the growth of the United States westward across North America, by treaty, purchase, war and settlement.
  • Consolidation: making the United States one stronger, united nation under one federal government.
  • Federal government: the national government in Washington (President, Congress and Supreme Court), as opposed to the governments of the separate states.
  • Frontier: the moving edge of white American settlement, beyond which lay land still held by Native American nations.
  • Union: the United States as one nation; in the Civil War, the side of the North.
  • Interpretation: in Paper 1 Section A, a view of events written or spoken by someone who lived through them or took part in them.

Interpretation A: Adapted from the memoirs of a man who served as a Union army officer from 1861 to 1865 and then moved to Nebraska, published in 1893.

After the war he worked as a land agent for a railroad company, selling its land to settlers.

He was later elected to the Nebraska state legislature as a Republican.

(written for this practice)

Study note

When I was a boy the country was two countries pretending to be one.

The South had its slaves and the North had its mills, and the West was a blank on the map.

The war settled the first question for ever, and the railroad settled the second.

Today a man can ride from New York to San Francisco in a week, under one flag and one law.

Farms stand where the buffalo grazed.

This is one nation now, and it was made by blood and iron.

Interpretation B: Adapted from an interview in 1937 with a woman who had been born into slavery in Georgia in 1855, recorded by a government project collecting the memories of formerly enslaved people.

After emancipation her family worked as sharecroppers.

In 1879 she moved to Kansas with her husband, and later lived in Topeka.

(written for this practice)

Study note

They told us the war made us free and made us citizens.

For a while it seemed true.

My father voted and we had a schoolhouse.

Then the soldiers went home and the night riders came, and the vote was gone.

We went to Kansas because Georgia was still the old Georgia with a new name.

The nation was put back together, all right.

It was put back together for white folks, and we were left outside the door.

Worked example 1: reading every word of an attribution (the Question 2 skill)

Before you write a word of Question 2, take each attribution apart.

Here is the checklist applied to Interpretation A above.

1. Who? A Union officer in the Civil War. He fought for the side that won and that saved the Union.

2. What did he do later? A land agent for a railroad company in Nebraska, then a Republican politician. His living and his career depended on the railroads and on settlers buying land.

3. When did he write? 1893, after the railroads had crossed the continent and the Plains had been settled. He wrote at the moment the frontier was declared closed, looking back with pride.

4. Why and for whom? Memoirs for the public. He wanted to show his generation's achievement.

Answer (the half of a Question 2 answer about A): "The author of A fought for the Union and then made his living selling railroad land to settlers in Nebraska, so he sees the Civil War and the railroads as the two great forces that united the nation.

Writing in 1893 as a Republican politician, when the Plains were settled and the transcontinental lines complete, he tells the story of a success he helped to build."

This ties named details of the author to his view.

"A is biased because he was a soldier" would stay at Level 1.

Worked example 2: a Question 6 plan across the whole period

Which of the following brought more change to the United States in the years 1840 to 1895:

  • the expansion to the west
  • the Civil War?

Explain your answer with reference to both bullet points. (12)

1. Line of argument first. "The Civil War brought more change, because it ended slavery and settled that the federal government, not the states, held final power, and that decided how the West would be settled."

2. Expansion, developed. Texas, Oregon and the Mexican Cession made the country continental by 1848; the Oregon and California trails, the gold rush and the Mormon settlement; the Homestead Act and the transcontinental railroad (1869) put farms on the Plains; the Plains Indians were confined to reservations, lost the buffalo and, after the Dawes Act (1887), much of their land.

3. The Civil War, developed. Eleven Southern states seceded and were defeated; about four million enslaved people were freed by the 13th Amendment (1865); the 14th and 15th Amendments made them citizens and gave Black men the vote; the federal government grew far stronger.

4. The link. The quarrel over whether slavery should spread west helped cause the war, and the war-time Congress passed the Homestead Act and the Pacific Railroad Act in 1862, which drove the later settlement of the Plains. So the war shaped how expansion happened.

5. Judgement. For the nation as a whole, the war changed more, because it decided the questions of slavery and federal power that expansion had raised. For the Plains Indians, though, expansion was the greater change: it destroyed their way of life.

Answer: Written out, this plan reaches Level 4 (10-12 marks): both bullets developed with precise detail, the relationship between them explained, and a judgement held from the first line to the last.

Without step 4 it is Level 3 (7-9 marks).

One bullet only, however good, cannot score above 6.

Exam tip

In this section, who wrote an interpretation earns marks only in Question 2.

In Question 1 and Question 3 comments about the author score nothing: in every series from 2022 to 2025, examiners kept Question 3 answers built on provenance, or on "less biased, so more convincing", in Level 1 (exceptionally Level 2).

Provenance is rewarded differently in Paper 1 Section B and in Paper 2, so do not carry this section's rules into those papers, or theirs into this one.

In Question 2, read every word of the attribution (job, age, where the author lived, what happened to them, what they did later, when and why they wrote, and for whom) and turn each detail into a reason for the view.

Common mistakes
  • Calling the authors of the interpretations historians. They lived through the events; that is why their position matters.
  • Answering Question 2 inside Question 1. Question 1 is only about what the two interpretations say.
  • Writing a page for Questions 1 and 2. Examiners comment in every report that these answers run far longer than 4 marks need. Four to six sentences is enough; save the time for Questions 3, 5 and 6.
  • Quoting or copying the interpretations in Question 1. In each series from 2022 to 2025 the weakest answers were almost all quotation, so name the difference in your own words and quote only a few words to support it.
  • Making the case for one interpretation only in Question 3. However strong, it is capped. Examiners single out spotting each interpretation's overall argument as what separates the best answers; line-by-line commentary hides it.
  • Mixing up the Mormons, the pioneer farmers, the Donner Party and the Homesteaders. They went west at different times, for different reasons, to different places.
  • Using events from outside the dates in the question. A question on the years before 1865 gets nothing for the Dawes Act, however accurate.

Check your understanding

1. Put these events in order, earliest first: the Dawes Act; gold found at Sutter's Mill; the Homestead Act; the Kansas-Nebraska Act. [2]

2. Name the Part of the course each belongs to: the Permanent Indian Frontier; Fetterman's Trap; carpetbaggers. [2]

3. Explain what "consolidation" means in this option, with one example. [2]

4. Using Interpretations A and B above: how does Interpretation B differ from Interpretation A about the consolidation of the United States as a nation? Explain your answer based on what it says in Interpretations A and B. [4]

5. Why might the authors of Interpretations A and B have a different interpretation about the consolidation of the United States as a nation? Explain your answer using Interpretations A and B and your contextual knowledge. [4]

6. Which interpretation gives the more convincing opinion about the consolidation of the United States as a nation? Explain your answer based on your contextual knowledge and what it says in Interpretations A and B. [8]

7. Which of the following was the more important idea in bringing about change in America in the years 1840 to 1895:

  • Manifest Destiny
  • abolitionism?

Explain your answer with reference to both bullet points. [12]

Answers

1. Gold found at Sutter's Mill (January 1848); the Kansas-Nebraska Act (1854); the Homestead Act (1862); the Dawes Act (1887). [2: all four in order 2, one pair swapped 1]

2. The Permanent Indian Frontier: Part one. Fetterman's Trap: Part two. Carpetbaggers: Part three. [2 for all three, 1 for two]

3. Making the United States one stronger, united nation under one federal government (1); for example the defeat of the Confederacy and the 13th Amendment ending slavery in every state, or bringing Utah's Mormons under federal law (1). [2]

4. Model answer: "Interpretation A says the nation was truly united by 1893, whereas Interpretation B says it was united only for white Americans and left African-Americans out. For example, A says the country is now one nation under one flag and one law, but B says that once the soldiers went home her people lost the vote and had to leave Georgia." Level 2, 4 marks: one overall difference about how far the nation was united, with matched detail from both. "A is positive and B is negative" with nothing more stays at Level 1.

5. Model answer: "The author of A fought for the Union and then made his career selling railroad land in Nebraska and as a Republican politician, so he judges the nation by the victory and the railroads he helped to build; writing in 1893 he looks back on success. The author of B was born enslaved in Georgia and lived through Reconstruction and its end, when Black voters in the South were driven from the polls; she moved to Kansas in 1879, and she spoke in 1937 to a project recording the memories of formerly enslaved people, so she judges the nation by what it did for African-Americans." Level 2, 4 marks. "B is biased because she had been enslaved" stays at Level 1.

6. Plan: A's argument is that war and railroads made the country one nation; B's is that the reunited nation excluded African-Americans. Test A: the Union victory in 1865 ended secession; the transcontinental railroad of 1869 and later lines tied the economy together; Homesteaders settled the Plains; the census of 1890 said the frontier had closed. Test B: the 14th and 15th Amendments promised citizenship and the vote; but after federal troops left the South in 1877, white Democrats regained power, Black voters were driven away by violence from groups such as the Ku Klux Klan, and thousands of Exodusters left for Kansas in 1879. Relationship: they measure different things: A the political and economic unity of the states, B equal citizenship. Judgement: A is convincing about the Union and the economy, but B is more convincing about the nation as a community of equal citizens. Level 4, 7-8 with the relationship and judgement; both tested but no relationship: Level 3, 5-6; one only: Level 2, 4 at most.

7. Plan: line of argument (Manifest Destiny brought more change, because it drove the whole movement west and justified taking land from Mexico and the Plains Indians, but abolitionism made expansion a quarrel about slavery that ended in civil war). Manifest Destiny: the phrase of 1845; the annexation of Texas; the war with Mexico and the cession of 1848; the overland trails; later, the belief that settlers had the right to the Plains and the reservations policy. Abolitionism: anti-slavery societies, the opposition to slavery in the territories, John Brown, the anger at the Fugitive Slave Act; it made compromise impossible and pushed the North towards war and emancipation. Link: the land gained through Manifest Destiny raised the question of whether slavery would spread west, which gave abolitionism its power. Conclusion answering "more important". Level 4, 10-12 if both are developed, linked and judged throughout; no link: Level 3; one bullet only: maximum 6.

Ready for the next section?

Create a free account to read the rest of this free unit, save highlights, track your confidence and plan your revision.

Your next step

Put this topic into practice.

These tools belong to this free unit. Create an account to open them and save your progress.

Practice paper · Sign up to open

History 8145 Topic p1-aa: Option AA (Paper 1 period study): America, 1840–1895: Expansion and consolidation. Structured practice

6 questions · Paper 1A

Attempt the questions, check the mark scheme and record your own marks.

Create free account to open this practice

Other units and paper downloads depend on your plan. This unit has no Section A quiz; use its other practice and checklist.

Already have an account? Sign in →

Give your revision a routine.

Build a timetable, tick off daily tasks, catch up on missed work and opt in to weekly email reviews. Connect with your teacher when you want to share your progress.