The role of education: functionalist and New Right views
Why does every society send its children to school for more than a decade, and who gains from it?
Sociologists do not take the answer for granted.
Some see education as something that holds society together and gives every child a fair chance to rise.
Others see it as a machine that keeps the powerful in their place.
The answer matters to pupils (is the race fair?), to parents (does choosing a school make a difference?), to employers (does school produce the workers they need?)
and to governments (what should schools be for?).
On the papers, the role and functions of education feed Paper 1 Q01 to Q04: short "Outline" items, the Item-based 10-mark question, and the 30-mark Item B essay.
AS students meet this whole unit on AS Paper 1 (Education with Methods in Context).
This section teaches the two consensus views: functionalism, which sees education as meeting society's shared needs, and the New Right, which agrees with much of that but argues that the state runs schools badly.
The next two sections set the conflict views (Marxism, feminisms) and postmodernism against them.
Hold the whole map in your head, because every 30-mark essay on the role of education is a debate between these camps.
- Paper 1 Education is Q01 to Q04: Outline two (4), Outline three (6), an Item A question asking you to analyse two (10), and an Item B essay (30). Methods in Context (Q05, 20) and Theory and Methods (Q06, 10) follow.
- Outline items are point-marked: 1 for a point named in a word or phrase, +1 for one sentence developing it to the exact focus of the question. A generic point, or a concept named and not developed, earns 1 at most.
- Everything worth 10 or more is marked in levels: 10 marks in bands 8-10, 4-7, 1-3; the 30-mark essay in bands 25-30, 19-24, 13-18, 7-12, 1-6; Methods in Context (20) in bands 17-20, 13-16, 9-12, 5-8, 1-4, where points applied to education in general, not to the issue in Item C, cap the answer at 13-16.
- "Outline and explain" (Q06) credits no evaluation: two explained points, nothing weighed against them.
- "Two" means exactly two. One point, however good, sits in 4-7; a third earns nothing.
- In the Item questions, each point must grow from a different hook in the Item; examiners in 2022, 2023 and 2024 counted two ways built on the same idea as one. The Item's last line restates the question and is not a hook.
- In essays, theories set side by side with no weighing ("functionalists say X, Marxists say Y") cap the answer at 13-18 of 30.
- Questions of 10 marks or more are judged on good English, clear organisation and specialist vocabulary inside the levels; there is no separate spelling mark. Write legibly: an unreadable script earns nothing.
- Every scheme credits "other relevant material", so an accurate study or example that is not on a list still scores.
- The role and functions of the education system: including its relationship to the economy and to class structure.
- Function: the contribution an institution makes to keeping society as a whole running and stable.
- Social solidarity: the sense of belonging to a society and sharing its values, so that individuals feel part of something bigger than themselves (Durkheim).
- Meritocracy: a system in which rewards and positions are allocated by ability and effort (merit), not by family background, so status is achieved, not ascribed.
- Role allocation: the function of sifting and sorting people, through tests and qualifications, into the jobs that best suit their abilities.
- Human capital: the knowledge, skills and qualifications of a workforce, seen as an investment that raises productivity.
- Marketisation: introducing market forces of competition and consumer choice into areas, such as education, run by the state.
Functionalism: education meets the needs of society
Functionalists start from the idea that society is like a living body.
Each institution (the family, religion, the economy, education) performs functions that keep the whole system healthy.
Education is studied by asking what it does for society as a whole, not for one class or group.
Their account is a chain of reasoning: society needs shared values and skilled workers; the family alone cannot supply these in a complex modern society; so a separate institution, the school, takes over the job.
Émile Durkheim (writing in the early twentieth century; his lectures were published as Moral Education in 1925) named two functions.
- Creating social solidarity. Without a shared sense of belonging, individuals would pursue only their own desires and society would fall apart. School transmits society's culture, its shared beliefs and values, from one generation to the next. Teaching a country's history, Durkheim argued, gives children a sense of a shared heritage and a commitment to the wider group. School is also "society in miniature": pupils cooperate with people who are neither family nor friends and follow impersonal rules that apply to everyone, which prepares them for life in wider society.
- Teaching specialist skills. Modern industrial economies have a complex division of labour: thousands of specialised jobs that depend on one another. Education teaches the specific knowledge and skills needed to fill these roles, which builds the cooperation between specialists that holds a modern society together.
Talcott Parsons (1959), an American functionalist, built on Durkheim.
He saw the school as the focal socialising agency, a bridge between the family and wider society.
- In the family, a child is judged by particularistic standards: rules that apply only to that child ("she's the youngest, so she can stay up later"). Status is ascribed, fixed at birth.
- In wider society, and above all at work, people are judged by universalistic standards: the same rules and tests for everyone. Status is achieved through effort and ability.
- School is where the child moves from one to the other. Everyone sits the same exams and follows the same rules, so pupils learn to accept universalistic standards and to see achieved status as fair.
- Parsons saw schools as meritocratic: everyone has an equal chance, and rewards follow effort and ability. Pupils who fail learn that failure is their own responsibility, which makes the outcome seem legitimate.
- Schools also perform role allocation: they assess pupils and match them to the jobs that suit their talents.
Kingsley Davis and Wilbert Moore (1945) put role allocation at the centre of their theory of stratification.
Some jobs are more functionally important than others (a surgeon against a car park attendant), and talent is scarce.
Society therefore attaches higher rewards to the most important jobs, so that the most able compete for them.
Education is the proving ground where talent is identified and people are sifted and sorted into the positions their ability fits.
Inequality, on this view, is necessary and functional: it motivates people to train.
The link to the economy: human capital
Functionalists tie education directly to the economy.
Theodore Schultz (1961) developed human capital theory: spending on education is an investment, like spending on machinery, because a more skilled workforce produces more.
This idea has shaped UK policy for decades.
Governments justify raising the participation age (in England, young people must stay in education or training until 18, under the Education and Skills Act 2008), expanding higher education and reforming vocational qualifications by arguing that the UK's economic success depends on its people's skills.
Evaluating functionalism
Every evaluation point below is built the way a top-band essay needs it: claim, evidence, explanation, judgement back on the view.
- Meritocracy is a myth (the Marxist critique). Functionalists claim rewards follow merit. Yet in England in 2025/26, disadvantaged pupils were 15.1 Attainment 8 points behind other pupils at the end of Key Stage 4 (Department for Education, provisional, published October 2026). If ability were evenly spread across classes, such a large and lasting gap would not appear. This weakens the functionalist claim because it suggests class background, not merit, shapes outcomes. A functionalist could reply that the gap has narrowed at times, so meritocracy is a goal being approached; but the narrowing has been slow and uneven.
- Davis and Moore's argument is circular. Melvin Tumin (1953) pointed out that we know a job is important only because it is well paid, and it is well paid because it is important. Many vital, low-paid jobs (care workers, cleaners) show that pay does not follow functional importance. This limits role allocation as an explanation of why education sorts people the way it does.
- Schools may not transmit shared values. Interactionists point out that pupils do not passively absorb a single culture. Paul Willis (1977) found that a group of working-class "lads" rejected the school's values altogether (see the Marxist section), and Colin Lacey (1970) showed anti-school subcultures forming among pupils in lower streams (see the subcultures section). Dennis Wrong (1961) called this kind of theory an "over-socialised" view of people: it assumes everyone absorbs the values they are taught. So the functionalist picture of value consensus ignores conflict inside schools.
- What do schools teach for work? Critics argue that much of what schools teach (a broad academic curriculum) has little to do with specific jobs, which questions the claim that education closely fits the division of labour. Functionalists reply that general skills such as literacy, numeracy and self-discipline are what most jobs need.
Note how the third point names its study.
Named evidence earns credit; "some people say pupils rebel" is anecdote.
The New Right: the same goals, a different route
The New Right is a conservative political perspective, influential since the 1980s.
It shares much with functionalism: it believes some people are naturally more talented than others, that education should be meritocratic and should socialise pupils into shared values (including a national identity), and that it should serve the needs of the economy.
Where it differs is on who should run schools.
The New Right's chain of reasoning runs like this.
State education is a monopoly: one provider, run by the state, with no competition.
Monopolies have no incentive to improve, because their customers cannot go elsewhere.
So standards stay low, and pupils, parents and the economy all suffer.
The solution is marketisation: make schools compete for pupils, as businesses compete for customers.
Funding follows pupils, so a school that fails to attract them loses money and must improve or close.
Parents become consumers who choose, a situation sometimes called parentocracy.
John Chubb and Terry Moe (1990), two American New Right writers, compared state and private schools in the United States, using national survey data on pupils, teachers and schools.
They argued that state schools had failed to create equal opportunity, and that private schools, which answer to paying customers, were better organised and got better results, including for pupils from low-income families.
They proposed that every family be given a voucher to spend at the school of its choice.
The state's role shrinks to setting a framework: a national curriculum to ensure a shared culture, and published results so that parents can judge schools.
These ideas shaped UK policy directly.
The Education Reform Act 1988 brought in the national curriculum, published league tables, open enrolment and formula funding (the policy section on marketisation teaches these in full).
Later governments extended the market through academies and free schools.
Evaluating the New Right
- Choice is not equal (Ball; Gewirtz). Stephen Ball (1994) argued that parentocracy is a myth: it makes the market look fair while middle-class parents, with more economic and cultural capital, are better able to choose. Sharon Gewirtz (1995), studying 14 London secondary schools, found middle-class "privileged-skilled choosers" used their knowledge and money to win places at the best schools. This weakens the New Right view because the market reproduces class inequality, the very problem it claimed to solve.
- Contradictions in the policy. The New Right wants to reduce the state's role, yet it imposes a national curriculum and inspections, which increase central control. This internal tension suggests the market is never left to run on its own.
- Real gains in some places. Supporters point to rising results in some converted academies and to schools improving under competition. The evidence is mixed: gains are not found everywhere, and much depends on which pupils a school admits.
Overall, functionalism and the New Right explain the official aims of education well: shared values, skills, sorting by merit.
They explain much less well why outcomes still follow class, gender and ethnicity, which is why conflict theories are needed to judge them.
Outline two functions that education may perform for the economy, according to functionalists. [4]
Answer.
- Teaching specialist skills (1): schools teach the particular knowledge and skills needed for the many specialised jobs in a modern division of labour, so the economy has workers to fill them (+1).
- Role allocation (1): exams sift and sort pupils by ability, so the most talented are matched to the most functionally important jobs, making the economy more efficient (+1).
Total 4. "Education gets people jobs" with no mechanism would earn 1 at most, because it does not say how the function works.
Item A
Pupils in the same school follow the same rules and sit the same examinations, whatever their family background.
Lessons pass on a common history and shared values to each new generation.
Education may help to hold society together.
(written for this practice)
Applying material from Item A, analyse two ways in which education may help to hold society together. [10]
Plan. Hook 1: same rules and exams (universalistic standards, Parsons).
Hook 2: common history and shared values (social solidarity, Durkheim).
The last line restates the question and is not a hook.
Model answer.
One way is through the universalistic standards Item A describes: pupils "follow the same rules and sit the same examinations, whatever their family background".
Parsons argued that the family judges children by particularistic standards, but school applies one set of rules to everyone.
Pupils learn to accept being judged by impersonal rules, the standards that operate in the workplace and in law.
Because everyone accepts the same rules as fair, people with different backgrounds can cooperate, which holds society together.
However, this works only if pupils see the system as fair; Marxists argue that unequal results by class show the rules are not neutral, and pupils who see this may reject the rules.
A second way is through the transmission of culture, Item A's "common history and shared values".
Durkheim argued that teaching a society's history gives children a sense of shared heritage and of belonging to something bigger than themselves, which he called social solidarity.
In England the national curriculum sets common content for maintained schools, and many academies follow it closely, so pupils across the country learn some of the same story of their society.
This creates the value consensus functionalists see as the basis of order.
Yet the extent of this depends on whose history is taught: critics of an ethnocentric curriculum argue that some minority ethnic pupils may not recognise themselves in it, which weakens its integrating effect.
Band: 8-10. Two different hooks, each named, each developed with a concept and a sociologist to the question's outcome (holding society together), each with an evaluative "extent" line.
Weaker answer (4-7). The same first paragraph, then a second paragraph about how schools teach skills for jobs.
That point is not from Item A, so the second application is lost.
Weaker still (1-3): one paragraph using "Education may help to hold society together" as if it were a hook, restating that education creates consensus with no concept or study.
Item B
Some sociologists argue that the main role of education is to serve the needs of the economy.
Schools and colleges equip young people with the knowledge, skills and qualifications that employers require, and they sort pupils into suitable occupations.
However, other sociologists argue that education serves the interests of powerful groups.
It may prepare pupils to accept inequality at work, while other roles, such as passing on shared values, are also important.
(written for this practice)
Applying material from Item B and your knowledge, evaluate the view that the main role of education is to serve the needs of the economy. [30]
Two-line plan. For: functionalist skills and role allocation, human capital, vocationalism (Item B paragraph 1).
Against: Marxist "needs of capitalism, not the economy as a whole"; Durkheim's solidarity and other roles; feminist and postmodern points; conclusion: serving the economy is a central role, but whose economy and at what cost is the real debate.
Model answer.
The view in Item B is that schools exist mainly to give the economy skilled, qualified and sorted workers.
I will argue that this is one of education's most important roles, but that "the needs of the economy" hides a question about whose needs are served, and that education also has roles beyond the economy.
The case for the view comes first from functionalism.
Durkheim argued that a modern economy rests on a complex division of labour, so schools must teach specialist skills.
Item B's "knowledge, skills and qualifications that employers require" is this function.
Davis and Moore (1945) add role allocation: exams sift and sort pupils so that the most able reach the most functionally important jobs, which Item B calls sorting pupils "into suitable occupations".
Human capital theory (Schultz, 1961) treats spending on schooling as investment that raises productivity.
This view is strong because it explains why governments of every party justify education reform in economic terms, from raising the participation age to 18 to the creation of T levels in 2020.
However, the strength of the view depends on schools actually matching talent to jobs, and the persistence of a 15.1-point Attainment 8 gap between disadvantaged and other pupils in England in 2025/26 suggests sorting follows class as much as ability.
The New Right supports the view from another angle.
Chubb and Moe (1990) argued that state schools fail the economy because they lack competition, so marketisation is needed to raise standards.
This strengthens the claim that education should serve the economy, but it is a claim about what education ought to do; the very need for reform admits that schools have not been serving the economy well, which weakens the view as a description.
Marxists accept that education is tied to the economy but reject the idea that it serves "the economy" as a neutral whole.
Bowles and Gintis (1976) argued, through the correspondence principle, that schooling mirrors the workplace: hierarchy, extrinsic rewards and fragmented tasks prepare working-class pupils to be obedient, alienated workers.
This is Item B's second paragraph, "accept inequality at work".
This evaluation is powerful because it accepts the economic link but turns it round: education serves the needs of capitalism and the ruling class, not the needs of everyone.
Yet Willis (1977) showed that working-class "lads" rejected school's values, so reproduction is not as smooth as Bowles and Gintis claim.
The view also underplays other roles.
Durkheim stressed social solidarity, Item B's "shared values", and Parsons the bridge from particularistic to universalistic standards.
These are roles for society as a whole, not just for employers.
Feminists add that schools have also transmitted patriarchal ideas, for example steering girls into lower-paid subjects and courses, which serves a gendered labour market more than an efficient one.
Postmodernists such as Usher and Edwards (1994) argue that in a diverse, flexible society education should and increasingly does serve individual choice and identity, not one fixed set of economic needs.
Finally, the evidence on vocational education tests the view directly.
If education served the economy well, vocational routes should be valued; yet the Wolf Report (2011) found many young people on vocational courses with little value in the labour market, and Finn (1987) argued that youth training schemes provided cheap labour and lowered unemployment figures.
This suggests that educational policy has often served political needs or employers' short-term interests, not the economy's long-term needs.
In conclusion, serving the economy is a central role of education, and functionalism and human capital theory are right that schools supply skills and credentials.
But the view that it is the main role is too narrow.
Marxist evidence shows the economic role is shaped by class power, and Durkheim's solidarity and the feminist and postmodern points show other roles matter.
The economic role is best seen as the most visible part of a wider role: reproducing and legitimating the society that exists.
Band: 25-30. A range of theories in conceptual detail; both Item B paragraphs applied and extended; every paragraph judges the view in the question; a conclusion that answers "main role".
Weaker answer (13-18). Three accurate, developed paragraphs, one each on functionalism (skills and role allocation), Marxism (the correspondence principle) and feminism (a patriarchal curriculum), using Item B's first paragraph.
Each theory is described in detail but never weighed against the view, and the conclusion says "there are many views".
This is juxtaposition, the commonest ceiling.
When a 30-mark stem names a view ("the main role of education is ..."), make every paragraph end with a sentence that weighs that view: "this supports / weakens the view that education mainly serves the economy because ...".
The same theories described one after another, with no link back, are capped at 13-18.
- Writing "functionalists think education is good". Too vague to score. Name the function (solidarity, specialist skills, role allocation, bridge to universalistic standards) and the theorist. It is tempting because the general idea is easy to remember.
- Treating the New Right as functionalism under another name. They share meritocracy and shared values, but the New Right's distinctive claim is that the state should not run schools as a monopoly. Without the market argument, a New Right paragraph earns little.
- Confusing universalistic and particularistic standards. The family is particularistic (rules for this child); school and work are universalistic (one rule for all). Students reverse them because "universal" sounds like "home life is universal".
- Learned criticisms with no weighing. "Functionalism is too positive" earns nothing alone. Say what the evidence shows and what it does to the view.
- Ignoring "including its relationship to the economy and to class structure". Essays on the role of education should cover both links: skills and work (economy) and sorting and inequality (class structure).
Check your understanding
1. Outline two reasons why New Right thinkers favour competition between schools. [4]
2. Outline three functions of education identified by functionalist sociologists. [6]
3. Read Item A below and answer the question that follows.
Item A
Teachers assess pupils' work against the same criteria and award grades that open or close routes into further study.
Schools also expect pupils to accept that results reflect their own effort and ability.
Education may play a part in role allocation.
(written for this practice)
Applying material from Item A, analyse two ways in which education may play a part in role allocation. [10]
4. Read Item B below and answer the question that follows.
Item B
Functionalist sociologists see education as performing vital functions for society.
Schools pass on shared values, teach the skills a complex economy needs and select the most able pupils for the most important positions.
On this view, education is meritocratic.
However, critics point to persistent differences in achievement between social groups.
They question whether education is fair and whose interests it really serves.
(written for this practice)
Applying material from Item B and your knowledge, evaluate functionalist explanations of the role of education in today's society. [30]
5. (practice, not exam style) A student writes: "The New Right and functionalists agree about everything to do with education." Outline two points of agreement and one point of disagreement that show why this claim is wrong. [6]
6. (practice, not exam style) Match each idea to its writer: (a) universalistic standards; (b) the functional importance of jobs; (c) vouchers and competition between state schools; (d) human capital. [4]
Answers
1. Each point 1 + development 1, for example:
- State schools are a monopoly (1), so with no competition they have no incentive to raise standards; competition forces them to improve or lose pupils (+1).
- Competition gives parents choice (1), so schools must respond to what parents and pupils want, which New Right thinkers see as making schools more efficient and accountable (+1).
- Funding following pupils (1) rewards popular, successful schools and pressures failing ones to change or close (+1). Other relevant material should be credited.
2. 2 + 2 + 2, for example: social solidarity (1), passing on shared culture and history so pupils feel part of society (+1) / specialist skills (1) for the many jobs in a complex division of labour (+1) / bridge between family and society (1), moving pupils from particularistic to universalistic standards (+1) / role allocation (1), sifting and sorting pupils by ability into suitable jobs (+1) / acting as society in miniature (1), so pupils learn to cooperate with strangers under impersonal rules (+1). Two points that are the same mechanism are credited once.
3. Levels 8-10 / 4-7 / 1-3. Possible application: hook 1, the same criteria and grades that "open or close routes" (sifting and sorting through credentials, Davis and Moore; qualifications as signals to employers and universities); hook 2, accepting that results reflect effort and ability (meritocracy and legitimation, Parsons; pupils who fail blame themselves, so allocation is accepted). Possible analysis and evaluation: Marxists argue allocation follows class (the disadvantage gap), so allocation is by background presented as merit; Tumin on circularity; teacher labelling and setting mean the same criteria are not applied equally. One point only: 4-7. The restating line used as a hook: 4-7 at best.
4. Levels 25-30 / 19-24 / 13-18 / 7-12 / 1-6. Possible content: Durkheim (solidarity, specialist skills, society in miniature); Parsons (focal socialising agency, universalistic standards, meritocracy, role allocation); Davis and Moore (sifting and sorting); Schultz (human capital). Possible application: Item B paragraph 1 ("shared values", "skills", "select the most able"), paragraph 2 ("persistent differences", "whose interests"). Possible evaluation: Marxism (myth of meritocracy, correspondence principle, Althusser's ideological state apparatus); Tumin; interactionist evidence of labelling and subcultures (Willis, Lacey); feminisms (patriarchal curriculum); New Right (agrees on aims, not on state provision); postmodernism (diversity, no single shared culture); DfE attainment gaps; strengths (explains official aims, why credentials matter). Conclusion: useful for the intended functions, less useful for unequal outcomes. Functionalism described with no weighing: 13-18.
5. Agreement: both see education as properly meritocratic, rewarding ability and effort (2); both want schools to pass on shared values, including a national identity, and to serve the economy (2). Disagreement: the New Right argues state schools are an inefficient monopoly and need market competition; functionalists such as Parsons and Durkheim did not make that argument and assumed state schools could perform the functions (2).
6. (a) Parsons (1); (b) Davis and Moore (1); (c) Chubb and Moe (1); (d) Schultz (1).