Conformity: types and explanations
Why do people laugh at a joke they did not find funny, or change their answer in class after hearing three friends give a different one?
Conformity is a change in a person's behaviour or beliefs because of real or perceived pressure from a group.
It matters well beyond the classroom: it shapes what people eat, wear, buy and believe, how juries reach verdicts, and whether a bystander speaks up.
On the papers, conformity is examined in Paper 1 Section A (Social influence), in short definition and application items and in 16-mark essays that ask you to discuss explanations and apply them to people in a scenario.
AS students meet this whole unit on AS Paper 1, alongside memory and attachment.
You need to know two types of conformity (what kind of change happens) and two explanations (why it happens).
Keep the two pairs apart in your head: a type describes the depth of the change; an explanation names the motive behind it.
- Section A is worth 24 marks. Items run from 1 or 2 marks (a multiple-choice item, a definition) through 3 to 6 marks (outlines, limitations, applications) to an 8- or 16-mark essay.
- Items of 4 marks and more are marked by levels: the whole answer is read and placed in the band that fits best. Items of 1 to 3 marks are point-marked or banded (a clear, elaborated point earns the full 2; a muddled one earns 1).
- An 8-mark Discuss with no scenario is about 3 marks of knowledge and 5 of evaluation. With a short stimulus it becomes 3 knowledge, 2 application and 3 evaluation.
- A 16-mark Discuss with no scenario is 6 marks of knowledge and 10 of evaluation. With "Refer to [name] in your answer" it is 6 knowledge, 4 application and 6 evaluation.
- Caps: if a question names two things (two explanations, two people) and you cover only one, the answer is held to Level 2 of four. On a short application item with no link to the scenario, the most you can earn is 1 mark.
- Schemes end with "Credit other relevant material": any accurate, relevant psychology scores, even if it is not among the listed points.
Two types of conformity
- Types of conformity: internalisation, and compliance.
- Explanations for conformity: informational social influence and normative social influence.
- Internalisation: a deep type of conformity in which a person publicly changes their behaviour and privately accepts the group's view as correct, so the change lasts even when the group is not present.
- Compliance: a shallow type of conformity in which a person publicly goes along with the group but privately keeps their own view, so the change stops when the group's pressure is removed.
- Informational social influence (ISI): conformity that happens because a person wants to be right and looks to others whose judgement they trust when they are unsure.
- Normative social influence (NSI): conformity that happens because a person wants to be liked and accepted, and fears rejection or ridicule if they stand out.
The first Key terms line is your list to learn word for word: two types, and only two.
The test for which type you are looking at is always the same pair of questions.
Did the person's private belief change?
Does the new behaviour continue when the group is not watching?
Internalisation is the deeper change.
Think of a student who joins a running club, hears the coaches and older members explain why they warm up slowly, tries it, and from then on warms up the same way when training alone.
The behaviour has moved and so has the belief behind it, so nothing has to keep it in place.
Because the new view is now the person's own, internalisation tends to be permanent.
Compliance is surface agreement.
A new employee laughs along with colleagues who mock a television programme he secretly enjoys, then watches it happily at home.
His public behaviour changed; his private opinion did not.
As soon as the group is gone, so is the conforming behaviour.
Compliance
Internalisation
Public behaviour changes?
Yes
Yes
Private belief changes?
No
Yes
Lasts when the group is absent?
No, temporary
Yes, usually permanent
Usual motive
To be accepted (normative)
To be right (informational)
Two explanations: the two-process model
Morton Deutsch and Harold Gerard (1955) argued that people conform for two different reasons.
Each is a chain of reasoning, and you should be able to write each chain out in full.
Informational social influence is about the need to be right.
The chain runs: the situation is unclear or new, so I do not know the correct answer or behaviour; I assume other people know more than I do; I accept their view as evidence about reality; so I change my behaviour and my belief.
Because the belief changes, ISI usually leads to internalisation.
It is a cognitive process: it works through what you think is true.
It is most likely when a task is ambiguous or difficult, in a crisis where a decision is needed fast, and when the others seem to be experts.
Normative social influence is about the need to belong.
The chain runs: humans are social and want approval; standing out risks ridicule or rejection; so I go along with the group's norm in public to keep my place in it, even if I privately disagree.
Because the private belief need not change, NSI usually leads to compliance.
It is an emotional process: it works through how you feel about the group.
It is most likely with people whose approval you care about, and with strangers in a face-to-face setting where your answer is public and you could be laughed at.
The word "usually" in the diagram matters.
The links are tendencies, not rules.
A person who first complies to fit in can, after weeks of hearing the group's arguments, come to agree with them, so compliance can turn into internalisation.
A strong exam answer says so: it shows you understand the model and is a point of evaluation in itself.
Evaluating the two explanations
Every evaluation point below is built as point, evidence, explanation, link back.
The link back is the sentence that earns the evaluation mark, because it says what the evidence does to the explanation.
Support for ISI from difficult tasks. Lucas et al.
(2006) asked students to answer maths problems of varying difficulty after being shown answers said to come from three other students (in fact set by the researchers, and sometimes wrong).
Students conformed more to the wrong answers when the problems were harder.
This fits ISI: when a task is hard, people are less sure they are right and rely on others for information.
So the evidence supports ISI as an explanation of conformity in ambiguous situations.
A counterpoint: students who rated their maths ability highly conformed less on the hard problems, so ISI does not affect everyone equally, and the explanation needs individual differences added to it.
Support for ISI from estimation tasks. Jenness (1932) asked students to estimate the number of beans in a jar, alone and then after a group discussion.
Their second private estimates moved towards the group's estimate.
Because the change showed up in private, the students seem to have accepted the group's view as information, which is internalisation produced by ISI.
Support for NSI from public and private answers. In Asch's line-judgement research (taught in the next section), when the naive participant was allowed to write answers down privately while the others still answered aloud, conformity fell sharply (to about 12.5% of critical trials, from 36.8%).
Interviewed afterwards, many participants in the public version said they had gone along with the group because they felt self-conscious and feared disapproval.
Removing the public element removed most of the pressure to fit in, which is exactly what NSI predicts.
Individual differences in NSI. McGhee and Teevan (1975) found that students with a strong need for affiliation (a strong wish to be liked and to belong) were more likely to conform.
This supports NSI, because the people most motivated by acceptance are the ones most affected.
It also limits the explanation: NSI is not a single process that works the same way in everyone, so a general explanation (a nomothetic one, in the language of the Issues and debates notes) misses how much people differ.
A limitation: the two processes are hard to separate. Deutsch and Gerard present ISI and NSI as two distinct routes, but in real situations they usually act together.
In Asch's research, a single dissenting partner reduced conformity.
That partner could have reduced NSI (the participant was no longer alone, so rejection felt less likely) or ISI (the partner was an independent source of information showing the majority might be wrong).
Because one finding fits both processes, it is often impossible to tell which one caused the conformity.
This weakens the two-process model as a precise explanation, even if it is a useful description.
Culture. Bond and Smith (1996) combined 133 Asch-type studies from 17 countries and found higher conformity in collectivist cultures, which value group harmony, than in individualist ones such as the USA and the UK.
The strength of NSI seems to depend on cultural norms about fitting in, so an explanation built mostly on American students may not generalise.
This links to cultural bias, a debate you will argue in the Issues and debates notes (A-level content).
What a weak evaluation point looks like. "Asch's study lacked ecological validity because it used lines."
The point is generic, and it does not say what the problem does to ISI or NSI.
A strong version: "Because judging lines matters little to participants, the NSI shown in Asch's research may be weaker or stronger than in real groups where people care about the issue, so the size of normative influence in everyday life cannot be read straight from the lab finding."
What is meant by internalisation in the context of conformity?
(2 marks)
Model answer. Internalisation is when a person changes both their public behaviour and their private view to match a group, because they have come to accept the group's view as right (1: definition with the defining feature, public and private change).
So the new behaviour continues even when the group is not there, for example someone who keeps cooking meat-free meals on their own after flatmates convinced them it is healthier (1: elaboration by consequence and example).
Weaker answer (1 of 2). "Internalisation is when you internalise the group's beliefs and conform to them."
The first half repeats the term (tautology) and earns nothing; "conform to them" with the idea of belief scrapes 1 mark at most.
The defining feature, private acceptance, has to be explicit.
Zainab has just started work at a busy hotel reception.
A guest asks her where the fire assembly point is; Zainab does not know, so she watches what the two experienced receptionists do and copies them when the next guest asks.
A week later she gives the same directions when working alone.
Every evening the receptionists also complain loudly about the manager.
Zainab joins in when they are there, although she thinks the manager is fair, and she says nothing against him to anyone else.
Use your knowledge of conformity to explain Zainab's behaviour.
(4 marks)
Model answer, each hook named.
- Hook: Zainab is new and does not know the answer. Concept: informational social influence. Explanation: in an unclear situation she treats the experienced receptionists as a source of correct information, because she wants to be right (1).
- Hook: she gives the same directions when working alone a week later. Concept: internalisation. Explanation: the change continues without the group, so she has privately accepted their answer, not just copied it in public (1).
- Hook: she joins in the complaints only when the receptionists are present. Concept: normative social influence. Explanation: she wants to be accepted by colleagues she must work with every day and fears being seen as an outsider (1).
- Hook: she thinks the manager is fair and says nothing against him elsewhere. Concept: compliance. Explanation: her public behaviour changed but her private view did not, so the behaviour stops when the group is absent (1).
Weaker answer (1 of 4). "Zainab conforms because she wants to fit in with the other receptionists.
People often conform when they are new to a job."
Only one concept is implied (NSI, not named), and the second sentence is common sense with no psychology.
It ignores the fire-exit detail, so ISI and both types are missing.
The next worked example is the full 16-mark essay with a scenario.
Plan first: two named explanations, at least four tied application points (two per person), and evaluation that keeps returning to the explanations.
About 500 words, in about 20 minutes.
Amara has joined a hill-walking club.
On her first walk, two members laugh at a new walker wearing trainers.
Amara thinks her own trainers are fine and comfortable, but before the next walk she buys walking boots and wears them to every club walk.
On walks with her sister, she still wears trainers.
Tomasz, also new, has never used a map.
When fog comes down, the experienced members decide to take the left fork at a junction, and Tomasz goes with them.
A month later, walking alone in fog at the same junction, he takes the left fork again.
Discuss two explanations for conformity.
Refer to Amara and Tomasz in your answer.
(16 marks)
Plan. Knowledge: NSI and ISI as Deutsch and Gerard's two processes; types each leads to.
Application: Amara (laughing, private view unchanged, boots only with the club) to NSI and compliance; Tomasz (no map skills, fog, experts, same choice alone) to ISI and internalisation.
Evaluation: Lucas et al.
(2006) and task difficulty; Asch's private-answer variation; McGhee and Teevan's affiliators; the two processes overlap; culture.
Model answer.
Deutsch and Gerard (1955) proposed that conformity has two causes.
Normative social influence (NSI) is the need to be liked and accepted by a group, so a person goes along with its norms to avoid rejection; it is an emotional process and usually leads to compliance, public change without private acceptance.
Informational social influence (ISI) is the need to be right; when a situation is unclear, a person treats others as a source of correct information and accepts their view, a cognitive process that usually leads to internalisation.
Amara's behaviour fits NSI.
Seeing members laugh at a walker in trainers shows her that standing out brings ridicule, and as a new member she wants to be accepted, so she buys boots.
Her conformity is compliance: she still thinks her trainers are fine and wears them with her sister, so her private view has not changed and the behaviour stops when the club is absent.
Tomasz's behaviour fits ISI.
He cannot read a map and the fog makes the situation ambiguous, so he looks to the experienced members as experts and follows their choice of route because he wants to be right.
Taking the same fork a month later, alone, shows internalisation: he has accepted their judgement as correct, so it guides him without the group.
There is research support for ISI.
Lucas et al.
(2006) found that students conformed more to wrong answers on harder maths problems, which shows that uncertainty increases reliance on others, as in Tomasz's fog.
However, students confident in their maths conformed less, so ISI depends on the individual: an experienced walker in the club might not have followed the group.
There is also support for NSI.
When Asch let participants write their answers privately, conformity on critical trials fell from 36.8% to about 12.5%, showing that much conformity in his public version came from fear of disapproval.
This matches Amara, who conforms only where the club can see her.
NSI does not affect everyone equally.
McGhee and Teevan (1975) found that students with a high need for affiliation conformed more.
Amara may conform because acceptance matters a lot to her, so NSI alone cannot predict who will conform; individual differences must be added.
A limitation is that the two processes are hard to separate.
A dissenting partner in Asch's research reduced conformity, but this could be because the participant feared rejection less (NSI) or because the partner gave independent information (ISI).
Real behaviour often involves both: Tomasz may also have followed the group because he did not want to be left alone in fog.
The two-process model therefore describes conformity neatly but cannot always say which process caused a behaviour.
Finally, Bond and Smith (1996) found higher conformity in collectivist cultures, which suggests NSI is shaped by cultural norms, so an explanation tested mostly on American students may not apply equally everywhere.
Level reached: Level 4 (13-16). Both explanations are accurate and detailed; both people are applied to with four clear hooks (laughing, private view, fog and expertise, behaviour alone); five evaluation points each end on what the evidence means for ISI or NSI; the answer is organised and uses terms precisely.
Weaker answer, in outline (Level 2, 5-8). A paragraph describing Asch's procedure and results in detail; one line saying "Amara conforms because of NSI because she wants to fit in"; no mention of Tomasz, so ISI is never applied; evaluation limited to "Asch used only American men, so it is gender biased" with no link to either explanation.
It loses marks for describing a study instead of the explanations, covering only one person, and making a generic point that says nothing about NSI or ISI.
In a conformity scenario, give every explanation its own stem detail and say why that detail fits: "Tomasz cannot read a map and it is foggy, so the situation is ambiguous, which triggers ISI".
Copying the scenario and adding a label ("this is ISI") earns little.
Check that each person in the stem has at least two tied points before you start evaluating.
- Mixing up types and explanations. "Compliance is wanting to be liked" defines NSI, not compliance. Compliance is a kind of change (public only); NSI is a reason for it. The two pairs are tempting to merge because they usually go together, so keep the table above in mind. In the 2025 essay on explanations, examiners marked down answers that described the types without linking them to ISI and NSI.
- Defining by repeating the word. "Informational social influence is when you are influenced by information" earns nothing. Use the defining features: the need to be right, uncertainty, others treated as better informed.
- Writing a third type of conformity. You need to know two types, internalisation and compliance. Other textbooks list more; for this course, answer with these two.
- Saying ISI always leads to internalisation. It usually does, but someone can follow an expert in public and still doubt them. Write "usually" or "tends to", and use the overlap as evaluation.
- Describing Asch's study in a question about explanations. A study earns credit only as evidence, with its finding and a sentence on what it shows about ISI or NSI. Long procedure descriptions do not raise the level.
Check your understanding
1. Which two of the following statements describe compliance?
- A The person privately accepts that the group is right.
- B The change in behaviour usually stops when the group is no longer present.
- C The change in behaviour is usually permanent.
- D The person's public behaviour changes while their private view stays the same.
- E It is usually caused by the need to be right in an ambiguous situation.
Shade two boxes only. [2]
2. What is meant by normative social influence? [2]
3. Kemi has just moved to the UK to study. At her first visit to a launderette she cannot understand the washing machines, so she watches the people around her, uses the same powder drawer and settings they use, and from then on always washes her clothes that way.
Use your knowledge of informational social influence to explain Kemi's behaviour. [4]
4. Outline one limitation of the two-process model as an explanation for conformity. [3]
5. A psychologist showed 24 college students a jar of marbles. Each student first wrote down an estimate of the number of marbles alone, then discussed the jar in a group of four, then wrote a second estimate alone. (written for this practice)
Explain why the psychologist asked each student to write down an estimate alone before the group discussion. [2]
6. Refer to the study in question 5. The second estimates were also written alone, in private.
Explain why this detail of the procedure suggests that any change in the estimates would show internalisation and not compliance. [3]
7. Leon says: "If someone conforms in public, it must be because of normative social influence."
Explain why Leon is wrong. [3]
8. Discuss informational social influence as an explanation for conformity. [8]
Answers
1. B and D (1 each). A describes internalisation (private acceptance). C describes internalisation, which persists without the group. E is the usual cause of internalisation (ISI), not compliance.
2. A type of social influence in which a person conforms because they want to be liked and accepted by the group and fear rejection or ridicule if they stand out (1). It usually produces compliance, a public change without private acceptance, and is strongest when answers are given in front of people whose approval matters (1). Credit other relevant elaboration, such as its being an emotional, not a cognitive, process.
3. Two levels, all four marks for application. Level 2 (3-4): ISI explained and clearly tied to two or more details. Possible application: Kemi is new to the country and cannot understand the machines, so the situation is ambiguous for her (hook) and she wants to be right (ISI); she treats the people around her as better informed and copies their settings, taking their behaviour as evidence of the correct way (ISI explained); she keeps washing that way on later visits, so she has privately accepted it, which shows internalisation, the usual outcome of ISI. Level 1 (1-2): ISI named or defined with weak or no link to Kemi. ISI described with no reference to Kemi: max 1.
4. Banded 3 / 2 / 1. For 3: the two processes are hard to separate in real behaviour (point); for example a dissenting partner in Asch's research reduced conformity, which could be because the participant feared rejection less (NSI) or because the partner gave independent information (ISI) (elaboration); so the model cannot always tell us which process caused conformity, weakening it as an explanation (consequence). Other valid limitations: individual differences (need for affiliation, confidence in one's own ability) mean the processes do not work the same way for everyone; culture changes the strength of NSI. A limitation of a study with no link to the model: max 1.
5. To give a baseline of each student's own judgement (1) so that any change in the second estimate can be put down to the group discussion and not to the student's original view (1). Credit: it lets the psychologist compare before and after for each person.
6. Internalisation means a change in private belief, not just public behaviour (1). Because the second estimate was written alone, no one in the group could see it, so there was no pressure to fit in, which removes the reason for compliance (1). If estimates still moved towards the group's view, the students must have accepted the group's information as correct, which is internalisation, usually produced by ISI (1).
7. People can conform in public for informational reasons too (1). For example, someone in an unfamiliar situation copies others because they think the others know the right answer, which is ISI, and the behaviour is public (1). The public or private setting does not decide the explanation; the motive does (need to be right or need to be liked), and ISI often produces internalisation, which includes a public change (1).
8. Levels, 7-8 / 5-6 / 3-4 / 1-2; about 3 marks of knowledge and 5 of evaluation. Possible content: Deutsch and Gerard's two-process model; ISI as the need to be right; others seen as better informed; ambiguous or difficult tasks, crises, experts; cognitive process; usually leads to internalisation. Possible discussion: Lucas et al. (2006), more conformity on harder maths problems, supports ISI; Jenness (1932), private estimates moved towards the group's, shows private acceptance; individual differences, confident students conformed less, so ISI is not universal; overlap with NSI makes ISI hard to isolate; cultural differences in conformity; real-world value (for example, people following others in an emergency). A Level 4 answer gives three developed evaluation points, each linked back to ISI. Credit other relevant material.